“Nuclear” Verdicts in the Trucking Industry: What You Need to Know


The trucking industry is currently facing a pressing issue that demands attention – the surge in nuclear verdicts. These verdicts, which involve over $10 million for payouts in legal cases, are casting a shadow over the industry’s operations. This article delves into the worrisome trend of escalating nuclear verdicts and their continuing impact on the trucking sector.

The Escalating Nuclear Verdict Trend

Nuclear verdicts have emerged as a significant challenge for the trucking industry. These verdicts, often involving multimillion-dollar settlements, have been on the rise, and their consequences are far-reaching. Such outcomes have the potential to not only drain financial resources but also tarnish the reputation of trucking companies. In many cases, these verdicts exceed the reasonable damages and can create a sense of uncertainty within the industry.

A U.S. Chamber of Commerce Institute for Legal Reform study found the following after a review of 154 litigation verdicts that involved trucking companies:

  • From June 2020 to April 2023, a mean plaintiffs’ award combined with settlements of $27,507,334 and a median award of $759,875.
  • For plaintiffs’ verdicts, the mean award was $31,862,776, and the median was $314,217.
  • For settlements, the mean award was $10,608,219, and the median award was $210,000.

Navigating the Impact

Addressing the issue of nuclear verdicts requires a multi-pronged approach. Trucking companies need to prioritize safety protocols, invest in driver training, and adopt advanced technologies, like AI integrated Dash Cams, to monitor and enhance driver behavior. Additionally, cultivating strong legal strategies and partnering with experienced attorneys can provide a defense against unwarranted verdicts.

Mitigating Factors

It’s important to note that the increasing prevalence of nuclear verdicts is not solely attributed to trucking company negligence. Juror biases, media portrayal, and a general lack of understanding of the complexities of the industry often play a role in these verdicts. Addressing these misconceptions and fostering informed discussions can contribute to a fairer legal environment.


The ongoing surge of nuclear verdicts poses a formidable challenge to the trucking industry. The substantial financial burdens, coupled with potential reputational damage, compel industry stakeholders to take proactive measures.

Make sure your company can tell the full story clearly with AI integrated Dash Cams that can help monitor driving patterns, be utilized in driver coaching, and protect you against Nuclear Verdict liability with video proof in HD clarity. Contact the Vestige team to learn more!

Share this resource:

Get A Quote

Vestige Voice Submission

Request Vestige Demo

Request Ping On-Demand & Asset Tracking Demo

Request Tool & Equipment Tracking Demo

Request Employee Safety Device Demo

Request Camera & GPS Demo